Common Mistakes in Setting Fresh Graduate KPIs

by | Jun 18, 2025 | KPI | 0 comments

Many companies hire fresh graduates to bring new ideas, energy, and skills to the workplace. These new employees are often eager to learn and ready to work hard. To help them grow and succeed, companies set Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), often called fresh graduate KPIs in this context. Fresh graduate KPIs are targets or goals designed to help measure how well these new employees are doing in their job while they adapt and develop their skills.

However, setting KPIs for fresh graduates is not always easy. Sometimes, companies make mistakes that can make these new employees feel confused, stressed, or even unmotivated. In this article, we will talk about some common mistakes companies make when setting KPIs for fresh graduates. We will also share simple ways to avoid these mistakes so that fresh graduates can grow and contribute better to the company.

Setting KPIs That Do Not Match the Job

One common mistake is giving fresh graduates KPIs that do not fit their actual job. For example, a new graduate in a marketing role might be given a target to bring in a large number of customers in the first few months. This is hard because they are still learning about the company, its products, and how to market them.

When KPIs do not match the job, fresh graduates can feel overwhelmed. They might feel like they are failing, even if they are working hard.

How to avoid this: Make sure the KPIs are linked to the tasks fresh graduates are responsible for. For example, instead of asking them to bring in many customers right away, give them goals like learning about the product, building marketing plans, or supporting senior team members.

Using the Same KPIs for All Employees

Another mistake is giving fresh graduates the same KPIs as senior employees. This is not fair because fresh graduates are still learning. They do not have the same experience or skills as people who have worked for years.

If the KPIs are the same, fresh graduates may feel they are not good enough or may not know where to focus.

How to avoid this: Create KPIs that are designed for fresh graduates. These can include learning goals, skills development, or teamwork targets. This will help them build a strong foundation.

Setting Unrealistic Targets

Some companies set targets that are too high. They want fresh graduates to perform like experienced staff in a short time. This can make fresh graduates feel stressed or burned out.

When people are given impossible goals, they may lose confidence or leave the job early.

How to avoid this: Involve fresh graduates in setting their KPIs. Discuss together what is reasonable. Make sure the targets are challenging but possible to achieve.

Focusing Only on Hard Results

Many companies focus only on numbers, like sales figures or the number of projects finished. They forget that fresh graduates also need to develop soft skills. These are skills like communication, teamwork, and time management.

If KPIs focus only on hard results, fresh graduates might miss the chance to improve these important skills.

How to avoid this: Add soft skills to the KPI list. For example, set goals like joining meetings, giving presentations, or working well with teammates.

Not Giving Regular Feedback

A big mistake is setting KPIs but not giving feedback. Some managers wait until the end of the year or the end of the contract to talk about KPI results. This can leave fresh graduates feeling unsure about how they are doing.

Without feedback, they do not know what they are doing right or where they need to improve.

How to avoid this: Give regular feedback. This can be done monthly or even every two weeks. Fresh graduates will feel supported and know what to work on.

Too Many KPIs at Once

Sometimes companies give fresh graduates too many KPIs. They want to measure everything. But this can make fresh graduates feel confused. They may not know which goal is the most important.

When there are too many KPIs, it is hard to focus, and performance may actually get worse.

How to avoid this: Choose a few important KPIs. Focus on the most critical goals that will help fresh graduates grow and succeed.

Not Updating KPIs as Fresh Graduates Improve

Fresh graduates learn fast. A goal that was right for them in the first month may not fit anymore after six months. Some companies forget to review and update KPIs.

If KPIs are not updated, fresh graduates may end up working on goals that are no longer useful.

How to avoid this: Review KPIs regularly. Make changes as needed so that the goals stay helpful and challenging.

Measuring Only Short-Term Success

Some companies only look at quick wins, like how many tasks are finished in a week. This can make fresh graduates focus on speed instead of quality. They might rush through work without learning deeply.

Focusing only on short-term success can also stop fresh graduates from thinking about long-term growth.

How to avoid this: Balance short-term and long-term goals. Include learning targets and improvement goals that will help fresh graduates succeed in the future.

Ignoring Company Culture and Values

KPIs often focus on tasks and numbers. But fresh graduates also need to learn about the company’s culture and values. If these are not part of the KPIs, fresh graduates may not understand how to work in a way that fits the company.

They might meet their targets but still not be a good fit for the team.

How to avoid this: Include culture and values in KPIs. For example, set goals related to teamwork, helping others, or joining company activities.

Failing to Support Fresh Graduates in Achieving KPIs

Sometimes, managers set KPIs but do not give enough support. They may expect fresh graduates to figure everything out on their own. This can lead to mistakes, slow progress, and low morale.

How to avoid this: Offer support, training, and resources. Make sure fresh graduates have what they need to meet their KPIs.

Conclusion

Setting KPIs for fresh graduates is an important task. When done right, it helps new employees learn, grow, and contribute to the company. But when companies make mistakes—like setting unfair targets, ignoring soft skills, or not giving feedback—fresh graduates can feel lost and unmotivated.

By avoiding these common mistakes and setting clear, fair, and supportive KPIs, companies can help fresh graduates become valuable members of the team.

Ready to start building your dream team? Discover and manage top talent more easily and efficiently with Hulu Talent. Click here to sign up now at app.hulutalent.com and begin your journey today!

 

Unlock Your Performance Excellence Now!

Subscribe to our blog to receive updates on the latest business developments and HR trends.